Evidence Needed To Contest a Will

Attorneys Real Estate Group

We Handle Real Estate Contracts, Builder Disputes, Failure To Disclose & More..

“When you die, you will use a testamentary trust to distribute your assets as you wish. In certain circumstances, however, it is necessary to challenge a will. There may be a misrepresentation of the testator’s intent in the choice if it is fraudulent or inaccurate.”

Contact Us For A Free, Over The Phone Consultation

It’ll Be A Helpful Discussion With An Attorney

Evidence Needed To Contest a Will

Other times, another party placed the testator under physical or mental duress. If you feel that contesting a will is necessary, you can do so in various ways.

Depending on your state and the circumstances of your case, the process of contesting a will differs. However, each state has its own set of laws concerning the type of evidence needed to succeed in a challenge. Let’s learn about the Evidence Needed to Contest a Will.


About Contest a Will.

The first step to contesting a will is to have standing, or legal authority, to do so. The right to contest a will usually depends on whether you would benefit from the contest.

You can, for instance, contest a choice if you would receive more from the estate if declared invalid. In contrast, you do not have standing if you would receive less from the estate — or nothing — if you were to invalidate the will.

It is still necessary to have standing to contest a will, but you may be able to do so if:

  • There is a will that you are the beneficiary of.
  • There is a newer well after the one in dispute, which benefits you.


The General Process of Contesting a Will.

Contesting a will might be possible in part or its entirety, though the latter is more common. It may also be possible to contest the amendment of a will or a supplement, especially if the revision occurred when a decedent lacked mental capacity or undue influence was involved. You can contest the amendment only in this case without contesting the entire will.

Contesting a will follows a general process:

  • If you’re considering contesting after probate, file your legal paperwork within the state’s statute of limitations. The clock typically starts when probate proceedings begin.
  • You must have standing, grounds, and evidence to contest a will, which an estate planning attorney can only do.
  • If you validate a will in the probate court, you should file a petition there.
  • The validity of the will be determined by a judge, depending on the evidence presented.


Why Contest a Will?

Contesting a will can be done for several reasons. You may feel unfairly left out, or you may think the person who wrote the choice was not of sound mind. The evidence you gather to support your case will depend upon your reason for contesting the will. This can range from witness testimony to financial records.

If you’re considering contesting a will, make sure you have strong evidence needed to contest a will in California to support your claims to convince the court the choice is invalid.


How can you contest a will?

Controlling a part of a will or even the entire will is possible. However, the latter is typically more frequent.

You might also be able to contest an amendment made to a will or a codicil, in particular, if the amendment was drafted when the deceased person was mentally incapable or had undue influence. You can contest the amendment without challenging the whole will in this scenario.

Here’s an essential procedure for contesting a will

  • Check to see if you comply with the statute of limitations in your state to file the required documents. The clock usually starts at the time that the probate process starts. However, you may be allowed to contest the probate. 
  • Get an estate planning lawyer to ensure you are in good standing and have the grounds and evidence required to challenge the validity of a will.
  • Make a petition to the probate court in the area where your will has been validated.
  • Based on the evidence submitted and the evidence provided, there might be a settlement or a hearing. A judge will decide on the legitimacy of the decision.


Costs to contest

Even if you’ve got an impressive case, the expense to contest wills can be something you should consider. Although you don’t need to employ an attorney, they could be the best option for winning your case and will tell whether you can win before you submit any papers.

You might spend thousands of legal fees, papers, and legal costs, which could take weeks or months. If you can benefit more from challenging the will than it would cost to challenge it, doing this could be worthwhile.


Factors To Consider When Contesting A Will

There are many aspects to consider when contesting a will’s validity. First, think about the cost. Before you pay a retainer to an attorney, look at your alternatives. If you’re not a family member and weren’t included in a previous will, you don’t have a right to contest the current will. And, if the person who made it had talked about inheritance with you, keep as many details as possible, and then estimate the value of the inheritance.

If the sum you receive isn’t enough to cover an appointment with an estate lawyer, It may be wiser to walk away. Even if it will cost twice the retainer amount, many of the most significant estate disputes will result in higher legal fees in addition to the inheritance. It would help if you think twice before hiring an attorney. 


The Importance of Evidence in Will Contest Cases

The success of a family-based provision claim is often contingent on the quality and quantity of evidence. Legal solid claims could be rejected if inadequate evidence does not support them.

Evidence can be found in various forms, such as evidence written in writing, testimonial proof, tangible evidence, expert evidence, records and information obtained from third-party sources, electronic and digital proof, evidence from medical professionals, and evidence from experts.


Adequate and Appropriate Evidence Needed To Contest a Will.

What evidence needed to contest a will near Orange County? To win a will/chances of successfully contesting a will, you must provide adequate and appropriate evidence, just like in most other legal matters. It’s not enough to contest a will simply because you don’t like the idea of the beneficiary receiving it.


Evidence Required Contesting a Will.


Why Evidence is Needed To Contest a Will depends on the grounds for contesting the will. Fraud or misconduct is an obvious one. If you have proof of the will forgery or that the testator received bribes in any way, you can contest the will immediately.

Someone under duress cannot make a testamentary gift in their favor. If a beneficiary has undergone coercion into signing a choice, that is grounds to challenge it.


Lack of Testamentary Capacity

Essentially, it knows what you’re doing and who you want to receive your assets when making your will. A person with mental impairment or incapacity may not be to blame if their will does not reflect their true wishes or if they suffer from cognitive impairment or inability.

Those who lack testamentary capacity can contest a will, even if they haven’t suffered a major mental illness. For example, this can also apply to people under significant financial pressure. People with a severe lack of education have a higher risk of making a will they don’t fully understand.


Contest a will on the grounds of duress.

It is basically when someone has to do or sign something against their will by force. Regarding choices, it may include threats of violence or taking someone’s livelihood away. This is more obvious than a forged document but is often difficult to detect.

Pressure exists in two types: constructive and actual. Actual coercion is when someone coerces or threatens another person into signing a will in their favor. Constructive force is when someone suborns the will of another, making it appear as though they should have an entitlement to the assets.


Lack of Probative Value

Probative value refers to how much weight a piece of evidence has in a court of law. Evidence that needs probative value is less significant. This could be due to several reasons, including gossip or illegally obtained evidence.

The probative value of ex parte evidence, which is evidence filed by one individual, and parol evidence obtained through oral agreements outside of a will must be higher. Evidence gathered ex parte that was collected without the participation of all parties.

The testator’s testimony can include testimony from their family members who were in attendance on their deathbed. Parol evidence also includes promises the testator made outside their will.


Disappointed Inheritance

Someone intentionally undervalues an asset in their will for this reason. Grandchildren may contest a choice because they have been disappointed in the inheritance if they discover that it was drastically undervalued in the choice if they are expecting a large inheritance from their grandparents.

It is common for someone to contest a will because they are disappointed in the inheritance they expected.


Can We Contest a Will If It Is Unsigned?

The short answer is no because it is already invalid if it has yet to be executed. To be able to make a will good in California, it must be in writing and executed by the decedent or a person authorized to sign it on behalf of the deceased and witnessed by two witnesses, each of whom has signed an acknowledgment that they were present when the deceased sign their will.

The more complex solution is that with a knowledgeable probate attorney’s assistance, an unsigned will may be a source of leverage. 

If it is proven that the testator intended to execute their will but could not sign it due to a mistake, there is a chance that a will not sign could be challenged in court and, in turn, contested. 

For instance, if there are only copies that are not signed of a will that was executed by a decedent and the witnesses who witnessed the deceased signing their will could affirm that it is an authentic copy of the will, the witness’s testimony could serve as proof extrinsic of the intention of the testator.


When To Consult A Probate Attorney Specialist

If you believe that the last will is not accurate in expressing the wishes of their loved ones, it is recommended that you seek advice from a probate attorney expert. The information and the possible results must be carefully considered. Most claims against the personal assets of the deceased could be filed within 12 years of that date. 

However, there are exceptions, for instance, the rectification lawsuit or a claim based on the Provision for Family and Dependents Act.

When the estate is going through massive administration, it is best to conduct initial inquiries. 

Third parties can take a while to respond to queries, and the memory of those who assist may diminish with time. The complexity of the administration of an estate can determine how a court decides to take action.


Bottom Line

Before challenging a will, consider your options carefully, as it can sometimes be costly and ineffective. Consult an estate lawyer to review your options to challenge a will.

A property lawyer can advise you about your chances of winning a contest before you enter it. If you are going to contest the choice, you need strong evidence and keep in mind that each state has different laws regarding the deceased property.

If you need to gain experience challenging probate registry validity, contact a probate estate expert like Attorney Real Estate Group; we’re knowledgeable and effective in probate challenges. There are deadlines for filing inheritance claims, and the decedent’s lack of testamentary capacity must be proven to establish inheritance claims.

Alec Stroup

ALEC STROUP Associate Attorney  Roseville Office  1-866-471-6981  info@attorneysre.com Alec...

Hedy Ghavidel

HEDY GHAVIDEL Managing Attorney  Roseville Office  1-866-471-6981  info@attorneysre.com Bio...